We've posted vintage cards for Rioja. You can vote up or vote down based on your opinion of vintage quality. We will be posting more regions soon.
Are you enjoying this format?
I like the simplicity of the cards and their format. I think the up/down voting is 1) too simplistic and 2) lacking details about the "why". For example, the 2013 Loire currently sits at -7. Was that 7 votes total, all down or for e.g., 35 total, 14 up and 21 down? At -7, was the whole region voted negatively, for all wines; white, red and sweet? I think there's value in allowing voters to describe why they selected up or down. This could become especially important for regions known for wines that need longer aging to mature.
It is a compiled number. If there are five up votes and 10 down votes then it would be a -5. There’s not really a practical way to make this more nuanced, however the comment area is a perfect place for people to post their more detailed perspective of the vintage.