Italy Part II: Central Italy

Central Italy comprises the heart of the Italian Peninsula, both geographically and historically. Lazio, which houses the capital at Rome, roughly corresponds to the ancient Roman city, while Tuscany equates generally to the older Etruria. Millennia later, Tuscany grew to become a major economic power in Italy, first as the Republics of Florence and Siena and later as the Grand Duchy of Tuscany. Before the Risorgimento, much of the rest of centraI Italy was made up of the Papal States, under direct rule of the pope and the Vatican. This guide will consider five regions as central Italy: Tuscany, Umbria, Emilia-Romagna, the Marche, and Lazio. 

Central Italy begins south of the Po River basin, and, like much of the country, is defined by the Apennine Mountains at its center. Its climate is varied by not only latitude but, importantly, elevation, with many of the top wines coming from higher sites. With Tuscany, central Italy serves as a powerful driver of the Italian wine industry, home to many of the country’s largest and oldest winemaking families, such as the Antinoris and the Frescobaldis. The initial sparks of Italy’s 20^th-century winemaking revolution were lit here, with the first bottling of Sassicaia in 1968 and the Super Tuscans that followed. 

Today, central Italy is no less dynamic. Italy’s most planted grape variety, Sangiovese, achieves its finest expressions in Chianti Classico and Montalcino. Nearby, in Umbria, Sagrantino has been reimagined for the production of dry red wines. Further north, Emilia-Romagna cultivates the best-known appellations worldwide for sparkling red wine with its various Lambruscos. White wine, too, finds prominence in central Italy, notably in the bottlings of Orvieto, the Malvasia blends of Lazio, and the Verdicchio wines of the Marche. In addition, winegrowers throughout central Italy continue to bottle cellar-worthy wines made from French varieties.

The Grapes and Grape Families of Central Italy

Malvasia: Perhaps the most complicated of the grape “families,” Malvasia refers to an extraordinarily broad range of varieties not only in Italy but across Europe. In France, there is Malvoisie; in Spain, various Malvasias; and in Portugal, Malmsey—an anglicization of one of Madeira’s noble varieties. Several theories have been used to debate the shared name. Ian D’Agata, for example, believes it relates to the Republic of Venice’s dominance of maritime trade, including that of wine. A number of sites in the Floating City continue to incorporate the name Malvasia, and, historically, wine bars were called malvasie. A second hypothesis suggests Malvasia is a bastardization of Monemvasia, the name of a Greek town that once served as a key port, eventually controlled by Venice, through which much wine traveled from the Greek to the Italian Peninsula. Though genetic testing suggests Malvasia varieties are not in fact Greek in origin, several wine styles across medieval Italy could have emulated the dried-grape wines made across the Adriatic.

Eighteen unique Malvasia varieties are registered in Italy, both red and white and offering a set of wines as diverse as any. In central Italy, four Malvasias, all white, are most important: Malvasia Bianca Lunga, Malvasia del Lazio (Malvasia Puntinata), Malvasia Bianca di Candia, and Malvasia di Candia Aromatica. Malvasia Bianca Lunga is most famously grown in Tuscany, where it historically has been an important component of the Chianti blend developed by Bettino Ricasoli in the 19^th century. Top Chianti and all Chianti Classico wines today exclude white varieties, but Malvasia Bianca Lunga remains essential to the production of vin santo, typically a blend to which the variety contributes body and aroma. Malvasia del Lazio and Malvasia Bianca di Candia are often interplanted and mixed in the white wines of Lazio, most notably Frascati. Of the two, the former is considered the superior variety, identified by its piney, rich mouthfeel, while Malvasia Bianca di Candia is more neutral. Malvasia di Candia Aromatica is unrelated to Malvasia Bianca di Candia. Its wines are floral and spicy, with monovarietal examples found in a handful of Emilia-Romagna’s denominations. 

Grechetto di Orvieto: Numerous Italian varieties incorporate some version of Greco into their names, a vestige of the Italian Peninsula’s affinity for Greek wines in the Middle Ages. Perhaps unsurprisingly, what is often discussed as Grechetto generally refers to two separate grapes: Grechetto di Orvieto and Grechetto di Todi. The latter is identical to Pignoletto.

In spite of its name, Grechetto di Orvieto is likely native to Umbria and shows some genetic ties to Trebbiano Toscano. The thick-skinned Grechetto di Orvieto shows good disease resistance, a benefit in the fog-dense regions where it is commonly grown. While its wines can be indistinctive, the best examples come from the tufaceous soils of Orvieto, where it is blended with Pignoletto and Trebbiano Toscano. 

Pignoletto: Synonymous with both Grechetto di Todi and Rèbola, as it is sometimes called in Emilia-Romagna, Pignoletto, like Pinot Noir, derives its name from the pine cone shape of its clusters. A vigorous variety, Pignoletto is perceived as higher in quality than Grechetto di Orvieto and is planted in higher concentrations near the Todi and Colli Martani DOCs, though the two Grechettos are frequently blended in each of these and a number of Umbrian appellations. There are also significant plantings of Pignoletto in Emilia-Romagna, with successful examples found in the Colli Bolognesi Classico Pignoletto DOCG. Its expression varies widely between the two regions, in each case characterized by what Ian D’Agata describes as a chamomile character, though the wines from Umbria have a stronger thiol-driven grapefruit quality.

Vernaccia: The name Vernaccia is used for an abundance of grapes with seemingly no common genetic link as well as, confusingly, a selection of wines made from non-Vernaccia varieties. The term comes from the Latin word vernaculum (native), though some theorize it refers to the Ligurian town of Vernazza. Vernaccia di San Gimignano may have been brought south to Tuscany from Liguria, where a Vernaccia grape was known to be grown. Some scholars claim the variety is related to Spain’s Garnacha (Grenache), especially in light of Vernaccia’s synonym Granaccia. Yet despite the shared etymology, those assertions seem unfounded.

Vernaccia varieties are found in several pockets of Italy, including Sardinia, where Vernaccia di Oristano is vinified into a Sherry-like fortified wine. The two most important Vernaccias, however, are both cultivated in central Italy: Vernaccia di San Gimignano and Vernaccia Nera. The former is white and has its own DOCG, and the wines range from simple and crisp to richer, slightly oxidative styles aged in oak. Vernaccia Nera is red, as the name implies, and harvested primarily in the Marche. It is known for its flamboyant, violet quality.

Sagrantino: While Sagrantino is widely considered indigenous to Umbria, it remains debatable whether this is the grape Hirtiola, mentioned in ancient texts by Pliny the Elder and Martial, as some attest. Despite its superlative quality, Sagrantino neared extinction in the mid-20^th century, before its resuscitation by such producers as Arnaldo Caprai in Montefalco, an area that continues to hold nearly all of Sagrantino’s global plantings. Commercial success has led to an exponential increase in plantings, which surged fivefold in Montefalco in the 2010s to more than 600 hectares as of 2020.

Sagrantino is late ripening and demonstrates exceedingly high polyphenolic content. The variety is robust in both pigment and tannin, leading to wines that are impenetrable in their youth. Top examples are long lived and celebrated among Italy’s finest red wines. Before producing dry wines, Sagrantino was traditionally used for sweet, red dried-grape wines.   

Lambrusco Grasparossa (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak)

Lambrusco: Lambrusco is not a single grape but, according to some counts, more than 60 varieties found throughout Italy. The best-known examples and the highest concentrations, however, are cultivated in Emilia-Romagna, where they are vinified into a range of sparkling red wines. Lambrusco varieties must not be mistaken for Vitis labrusca, a separate vine species native to North America, though the etymology is the same. Lambrusco translates to “wild grape,” and this series of varieties is said to be domesticated from wild vines. Accordingly, some Lambrusco varieties share characteristics with Vitis vinifera subsp. sativa, the subspecies for wild cultivars. Like wild vines, Lambrusco di Sorbara cannot self-pollinate. Though genetically hermaphroditic, its flowers display only female sex organs. To remedy its challenges with fruit set, the variety must be interplanted with a separate pollinator (often Lambrusco Salamino).

While a host of Lambrusco varieties have been identified, five are most important for quality and quantity. Lambrusco di Sorbara yields the lightest, most floral Lambrusco wines, while the thicker-skinned Lambrusco Grasparossa makes the most tannic and structured. Centered between the two is the most cultivated Lambrusco variety, Lambrusco Salamino, whose name refers to the salami shape of its bunches. These three are most associated with the province of Modena, while Lambrusco Marani is associated with Reggio Emilia and Lambrusco Maestri with Parma. Lambrusco Marani wines show both elevated tannin and acid, and Lambrusco Maestri wines are the most fruit driven and generous. 

Tuscany

The birthplace of the Renaissance, as it is often called, Tuscany has born some of the most influential thinkers and artists in the Western canon, among them Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, Dante Alighieri, Donatello, and Sandro Botticelli. Its regional capital, Florence, ranks among the world’s most visited cities, while Siena, Pisa, Arezzo, Lucca, and Livorno also attract tourists. Standard Italian is founded on the dialect spoken by Tuscans.

Tuscany (or Toscana) is also the historic home of Italy’s most planted grape, Sangiovese. The variety reaches its highest expressions here, evidenced in the wines Chianti Classico, Brunello di Montalcino, and Vino Nobile di Montepulciano. Citing the region’s global market appeal and commercial aptitude, in their book Vino Italiano: The Regional Wines of Italy, Joseph Bastianich and David Lynch call Tuscany Italy’s Bordeaux. Indeed, Italy’s finest Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot wines are made in Tuscany. Yet Tuscany’s vinicultural diversity extends beyond Sangiovese and Bordeaux varieties, encompassing a host of whites, sweet wines, and other indigenous grapes across a landscape shaped by coastal plains, mountain slopes, and even islands. 

Chianti and Chianti Classico

The precise origins of the Chianti region remain vague, with the name referring loosely to various points north of Siena and south of the Arno River in early maps. The land that today composes Chianti Classico was fought over in the late Middle Ages by the Republics of Florence and Siena. In 1716, Cosimo III de’ Medici, Grand Duke of Tuscany, officially issued a bando, or “edict,” that drew the boundaries of the Chianti wine region, roughly corresponding to the modern Classico zone, as well as of Pomino, Carmignano, and Valdarno. Collectively, these four are considered the earliest examples of demarcated wine regions, predating those of the Douro and Tokaj by several decades.

Efforts to improve quality and increase exports were formalized through the inception in 1753 of the Accademia dei Georgofili, a scholarly body focused on agriculture. Winegrowers looked to French practices to improve wine stability in an effort to expand Chianti’s foreign markets. The contemporary “formula” for Chianti wine is attributed to Bettino Ricasoli, whose family has owned the Castello di Brolio, in Gaiole, since the 12^th century. Ricasoli, who later became prime minister of Italy, inverted the typical blend by vinifying Sangiovese as the dominant variety, using the then more popular Canaiolo instead as an accessory. For younger-drinking wines, he also suggested a small addition of the white grape Malvasia Bianca Lunga. His contributions, however, extended far beyond encépagement. Ricasoli toured Burgundy and Bordeaux and adopted several winemaking practices. He shortened post-fermentation maceration periods and switched from using open-top to sealed fermentation vessels. He also advocated for lower vine-training systems. Additionally, Ricasoli transitioned his wines, which garnered several awards in the 1870s, to Bordeaux-shaped bottles, preferring them to fiaschi, the squat-shaped, straw-wrapped bottles associated with Chianti since the Renaissance era.

Challenges with fraudulent Chianti wine are documented as early as the mid-18^th century. By the late 1800s, amid the phylloxera crisis, fraudulent Chianti was traded globally. Tuscan producers outside the Chianti region began to label wines as vino tipo di Chianti (wine of the Chianti type), and copycat wines were produced as far away as California, where the Italian Swiss Colony sold Tipo Chianti in fiasco. In 1924, an Italian law legalized the labeling of a wine type rather than a specific region, a blow to Chianti producers determined to protect their exclusive right to market their region of origin. In response, Chianti winegrowers organized the Consorzio per la difesa del vino tipico del Chianti e della sua marca di origine (Consortium for the Defense of Typical Wine of Chianti and of Its Mark of Origin), a forerunner of today’s Consorzio Vino Chianti Classico. These producers also began to use a black rooster, or gallo nero, on their bottles, which is a mandatory symbol for Chianti Classico today. Over the following years, Chianti producers continued to battle neighboring winegrowers and the Italian government. Ultimately, the vino tipo concept was abandoned, but, despite that success, the Chianti region was officially enlarged in 1932 to include seven subzones: Chianti Classico, Rùfina, Montalbano, Colli Fiorentini, Colli Senesi, Colli Aretini, and Colline Pisane. (A final subzone, Montespertoli, has been included since 1997.)

Producers in Chianti Classico, the subzone that most closely adheres to Chianti’s historic boundaries, spent the remainder of the 20^th century attempting to differentiate themselves from the broader Chianti both legally and on the market. In 1967, Chianti was granted DOC status, and its subzones were further codified into law. Chianti Classico producers traded their fiaschi, which were associated with cheap wine, for Bordeaux bottles, which were used for the majority of Chianti Classico wine by 1969. More troubling was that the Chianti regulations demanded that 10 to 30% of wines be composed of the white varieties Malvasia Bianca Lunga and Trebbiano Toscano, an addition that, many Chianti Classico producers argued, diluted the wines.

Inspired by the success of Sassicaia on the Tuscan Coast, which was labeled as Vino da Tavola, Chianti Classico producers began to declassify their wines in order to evade regulations. In 1971, Niccolò Antinori blended Cabernet Sauvignon into his Tignanello wine, defaulting to the Vino da Tavola label rather than Chianti Classico Riserva, as the wine was marked in former iterations. A series of Super Tuscans arrived in Chianti Classico, and while some were made from French varieties (the most important was Merlot), others were monovarietal Sangiovese wines, a style uncommon outside Montalcino. The first, in 1968, was San Felice’s Vigorello (which today is instead primarily a Cabernet Sauvignon–Merlot blend), followed in the subsequent decades by such icon Sangiovese wines as Isole e Olena’s Cepparello, Fontodi’s Flaccianello della Pieve, San Giusto a Rentennano’s Percarlo, Fèlsina’s Fontalloro, and Montevertine’s Le Pergole Torte. Despite changes in regulation, each of these wines continues to be bottled as IGT. 

In 1984, Chianti was upgraded to become a DOCG. Relenting to mounting pressure from the success of the Super Tuscans, the new disciplinare allowed for up to 10% French varieties. Chianti Classico, however, formally separated from Chianti to form its own DOCG in 1996. Regulations were made more strict, with increased minimum alcohol levels, delayed release dates, and changes to varietal breakdown to allow for 100% Sangiovese wines and the addition of 15% French varieties, raised to 20% in 2000. In 2005, white grape varieties were prohibited entirely in Chianti Classico. Since 2010, it has been forbidden to produce Chianti within the bounds of Chianti Classico.

The noncontiguous Chianti DOCG covers a vast swath of the Tuscan landscape, much of which overlaps with several other DOC and DOCG regions. Chianti is divided into seven specified subzones: Rùfina, Montalbano, Colli Fiorentini, Colli Senesi, Colli Aretini, Colline Pisane, and Montespertoli. Colli and colline refer to the series of hills that define the Tuscan countryside, while Fiorentini, Senesi, Aretini, and Pisane refer to the Florence, Siena, Arezzo, and Pisa provinces, respectively. While Chianti is widely thought of as being cheaper and lower in quality than Chianti Classico, exceptions can be found. The most significant come from Rùfina, where vineyards are cultivated east of Florence in proximity to the Sieve River, a tributary of the Arno, between 200 and 500 meters in elevation and closer to the Apennines than the rest of Chianti. The Chianti Rùfina subzone intersects with the cold Pomino DOC, where Sangiovese is difficult to ripen and Pinot Nero, Merlot, Pinot Bianco, Chardonnay, and Sauvignon Blanc are favored. Chianti Rùfina wines are regarded for their elegance and longevity, and the producers Selvapiana and Frescobaldi are the subzone’s most recognizable. Chianti Colli Senesi, which encompasses both Montalcino and Montepulciano, also bottles some wines of note. 

Chianti Classico stretches between Florence and Siena, drawing ample tourists from these two highly trafficked cities. The terrain is winding, with steep hillsides and verdant forests. The hills help blockade the region from some of the harsher eastern winds, while the southern end of the DOCG is flatter and more exposed. The dynamism of the landscape provides for the incredible diversity of Chianti Classico wines, creating a series of distinct mesoclimates with varying exposures, elevations, and slopes. Two important soil types are noted in Chianti Classico: galestro and alberese. Galestro consists of a friable schistic clay, while alberese is a harder marlstone analogous to limestone. A third soil, macigno, is a grayish-blue sandstone, and another, calcareous tufa, is found in the south. Top Chianti Classico vineyards will usually consist of some combination of galestro and alberese.

Chianti Classico in autumn (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak for “Vinous”)

There is a strong push from winegrowers in Chianti Classico to enact subzones. As of 2021, producers can label their Gran Selezione wines with a unità geografiche aggiuntive (UGA), or "additional geographical unit." The UGAs identify specific villages or communes, and 11 have been approved. This development paves the way for wider adoption. Chianti Classico is grown is eight communes: Greve in Chianti, Barberino Tavarnelle, and San Casciano Val di Pesa are located in the province of Florence, while Radda in Chianti, Gaiole in Chianti, Castellina in Chianti, Castelnuovo Berardenga, and Poggibonsi are found just south in the province of Siena. The subzones mirror these, though Barberino Tavarnelle and Poggibonsi are grouped together to form the subzone of San Donato. Additional subzones include the hamlets of Lamole, Montefioralle, Panzano, and Vagliagli. 

The Chiantigiani often point to the specific character of Chianti Classico wines from different areas. Radda, for example, is home to the highest-elevation vineyards in Chianti Classico, at above 650 meters. Its wines are characterized by elegance, and, with the advent of climate change, vineyard land there has become increasingly desirable. Castellina, too, contains several high-elevation sites exceeding 500 meters, especially in its western sector. The area shows high concentrations of alberese and, overall, takes the shape of a sweeping amphitheater. In Chianti Classico’s northwestern corner, San Casciano Val di Pesa presents a north-south valley. Few icon wines are grown here, and examples are generally light and approachable. Quality is variable across San Donato, but one of Chianti Classico’s most pedigreed pockets is found in the area’s south, bordering Castellina, yielding powerful, deep expressions of Sangiovese. Greve features the noted hamlets of Lamole, Montefioralle, and Panzano. The latter has formed its own winegrowers association and is recognized for its Conca d’Oro, a galestro-rich, south-facing concave slope. Gaiole, like Greve, is heterogeneous in style and terroir. Wines grown in the Gaiole village of Monti are well renowned. Castelnuovo Berardenga lies furthest south. Generally warmer, Castelnuovo wines are recognized for their breadth and firm tannins. Some critics consider these wines to be a transition between Chianti Classico and Montalcino, though lighter examples are found in Castelnuovo’s western flank.

While Sangiovese has provided the core of Chianti and Chianti Classico since Ricasoli’s innovations, modern clones present important distinctions compared with those used prior to the late 20^th century. Historically, the most planted clones of Sangiovese, such as R10, R24, and F9, were favored for their high vigor and ability to produce large quantities of wine, rather than for their quality. These clones yield large berries and big bunches, resulting in somewhat anemic wines. In 1988, the Consorzio Vino Chianti Classico launched the Chianti Classico 2000 initiative, in search of superior clonal material that would provide thicker skins and smaller berries to increase the skin-to-juice ratio; produce looser clusters to minimize disease pressure; and ripen earlier. They commissioned 14 experimental vineyards under the guidance of the famous winemaker Carlo Ferrini and ultimately isolated seven new Sangiovese clones, widely used both in Chianti Classico and outside the region. Since the late 1990s, more than 60% of Chianti Classico vineyards have undergone replanting. The project also provided critical research into ideal rootstocks to reduce vigor while increasing sugar production, increased vine density (5,000 to 7,000 vines per hectare is now considered ideal), and vine training, with a move toward Guyot systems rather than the more historic bush vine, or alberello, training.

Chianti mandates a minimum 70% Sangiovese, while Chianti Classico requires 80%. Canaiolo remains an important complement to Sangiovese in Chianti and Chianti Classico wines. A midweight variety, Canaiolo enhances Sangiovese-based wines through greater finesse and precision. Canaiolo’s effect is opposite that of Bordeaux varieties, whose firmness and power can overwhelm Sangiovese. Malvasia Nera’s impact can be similar to Canaiolo's, but with heightened floral aromatics. A debate continues, however, over the exact identity of Malvasia Nera, as a handful of distinct varieties under that name are cultivated in Italy. (The one cultivated in Tuscany is likely Malvasia Nera di Brindisi.) As its name suggests, Colorino is often employed to add pigment to Chianti and Chianti Classico wines, darkening the otherwise light-red Sangiovese. Colorino is actually a group of anthocyanin-rich grapes, and its role is similar to that of Petit Verdot in Bordeaux. Ciliegiolo likely shares a parent-offspring relationship with Sangiovese, for which it has often been mistaken. Its name derives from the Italian word for cherry, an apt descriptor for this elegant, fruity variety. Mammolo, enjoyed for its aromatic intensity, refers to the Italian word for violet. More esoteric Italian varieties and, more prominently, Bordeaux varieties are also used in Chianti and Chianti Classico blends. Though entirely forbidden in Chianti Classico, white grapes may account for up to 10% of the blend in Chianti wines. 

Maintaining the forward-thinking spirit that helped propel the Super Tuscan movement, many Chianti Classico producers continue to experiment in the cellar today. Wines produced in the most traditional style are fermented and aged in large Slavonian oak botti, though stainless steel fermenters and élevage in barriques are widely practiced as well. Several producers are experimenting with cement vessels as well as amphorae made of terra cotta, a material that has a long manufacturing history in the area. Conversely, in Chianti DOCG, producers are still permitted to use the governo technique, so long as Governo all’uso Toscano is noted on the label. In this centuries-old practice, partially dried grapes (or potentially fresh grapes or must) are added midway through fermentation, particularly if it is stuck. With the introduction of temperature control and modern enology, stuck fermentation is rarely an issue today, and the practice has been widely abandoned. Historically, governo winemaking would provide the wines with a unique raisiny richness and structure as well as a distinctive fizziness. 

Both Chianti and Chianti Classico have instated quality pyramids, primarily determined by required aging prior to release, which is as follows:

In 2013, the Consorzio Vino Chianti Classico introduced a new highest designation, Gran Selezione, which took effect the following year retroactively for the 2010 vintage. In addition to undergoing a 30-month period of maturation, Gran Selezione wines must use fruit that is exclusively estate grown or acquired through long-term contracts, and harvested from a single vineyard or a selection of top parcels. As of 2021, they must contain at least 90% Sangiovese. The wines must also pass a tasting panel. While market reception has yet to fully embrace the Gran Selezione category, the hope is to allow producers to both take an initial step in communicating specificity of place and develop a portfolio of wines that can compete in price with Brunello di Montalcino and top IGT wines.

Chianti and Chianti Classico’s wine quality pyramids (Credit: Brandon Lee Wise)

Montalcino

Compared with Chianti and Vino Nobile di Montepulciano, Brunello di Montalcino could be considered a recent chapter in Tuscany’s history of winegrowing. The commune of Montalcino earned early praise, documented since the late Renaissance, for its white Moscadello wines, both sparkling and sweet. Francesco Redi, in his 1685 work Bacco in Toscana, described Moscadello di Montalcino as “divine.” Brunello, whose name means “small dark one”—a reference to the Sangiovese berries—did not come to fruition until the mid-19^th century. Pharmacist and natural historian Clemente Santi is credited with inventing the category. Though he would win an honorable mention for Moscadello from his Il Greppo estate at the Exposition Universelle of 1867 in Paris, Santi began bottling experimental red wines as early as the 1850s. In 1854, at the Exhibition of Natural and Industrial Products of Tuscany, in Florence, he presented what was likely a wine blended exclusively from red grapes—uncustomary at the time for Tuscan winemaking, which, like that of Chianti, classically relied on the inclusion of white grapes. An astute agriculturalist, Santi pioneered several vineyard practices that made quality red winegrowing possible in Montalcino, such as delaying harvest to increase ripeness. His 1865 red wine, at this point labeled as “brunello,” won two silver medals at the 1869 agricultural fair in Montepulciano.

Clemente was succeeded by his grandson Ferruccio Biondi Santi, who further modernized Montalcino’s wine industry in the face of oidium and phylloxera and isolated the Sangiovese Grosso biotype. Biondi Santi dedicated himself to producing red wines with long aging potential, bottling his “riserva” wines after several years of maturation in botti. He set aside bottles of the outstanding 1888 and 1891 vintages, a handful of which remain in the Biondi Santi cellar. Futher, it was Ferruccio’s work that solidified monovarietal Sangiovese, an unprecedented approach, as a defining characteristic of Brunello wines.

By the dawn of the 20^th century, only a few producers were bottling Brunello, and the ravages of World War I further stunted Montalcino’s nascent industry. Though surviving producers, such as Fattoria dei Barbi, Fattoria di Argiano, and Fattoria di Sant’Angelo in Colle (now divided into Il Poggione and Col d’Orcia), had joined by the 1930s, production remained small through the mid-century, despite a strong reputation for quality. Brunello di Montalcino was granted early DOC status in 1966, elevated to Italy’s first DOCG in 1980; its regulations have changed minimally since they were drafted. In 1967, Montalcino producers banded together to form their Consorzio for the promotion of the region’s wines. Several went on to hire Giulio Gambelli as a consulting winemaker, and his palate for Sangiovese has permanently shaped winemaking not only in Montalcino but also throughout Tuscany.

In the 1980s, Montalcino began a dynamic period of vineyard expansion. In 1967, there were only 12 producers of Brunello, a number that rose to 74 in 1987, and 208 in 2008. Similarly, planted hectarage grew tenfold between 1968 and 1988, from 80 to 875. The founding of Villa Banfi (now Castello Banfi) in 1978 by American-Italian brothers John and Harry Mariani brought additional attention to the appellation and increased demand for its wines, serving as only one example of large-scale investment in Montalcino. In the late 20^th century, a series of winemaking culture wars began throughout Italy—the arrival of many Super Tuscans and, in Piedmont, the traditional and modern divide in Barolo and Barbaresco—and Montalcino similarly split into camps of producers, some maintaining more established methods of Brunello vinification, and others leveraging practices to yield more opulent wines that would appeal to international audiences. Often, such wineries turned to smaller maturation vessels, commonly made from new French oak, and sought exaggerated ripeness and extraction.

At the turn of the millennium, many wine critics had taken note of increasingly darker-colored Brunello wines—suspicious for wines that should be entirely Sangiovese. It was unsurprising to some when scandal erupted in 2008, after several of Montalcino’s largest producers came under investigation for the potential inclusion of other grape varieties in their 2003 wines. Rumors spread about tanks of Nero d’Avola and bulk Spanish wine entering the region by night. The press termed the scandal Brunellogate or Brunellopoli. On top of meticulous government oversight and the forced declassification of more than one million liters of Brunello and Rosso wine, the circumstances temporarily damaged Montalcino’s reputation in many of its international markets. Some producers surmise that Brunellogate actually encouraged many of their colleagues to retreat to more restrained and traditional practices. Today, Brunello di Montalcino remains Italy’s most expensive wine, as of 2019 costing €1,085 per hectoliter in bulk, compared with €665 for Barolo and €272.50 for Chianti Classico.

Various wood fermentation and maturation vessels (Credit: Brandon Lee Wise)

Approximately 3,500 hectares of Montalcino are planted to vineyards, or 15% of the commune. A UNESCO World Heritage Site, Montalcino has reached its maximum allotted vineyard hectarage. Montalcino winegrowers must obtain rights to vinify Brunello or Rosso wines, the total of which have also been doled out by the Consorzio. A new producer wishing to bottle Brunello would need to purchase both the land and rights from another winery, which would then forfeit its production of Brunello.

Montalcino is a single commune, with the town of the same name sitting on a hill near the square-shaped appellation’s center. The landscape gently undulates, more open and less forested than Chianti Classico, as well as warmer and more exposed to the moderating effects of the Mediterranean Sea. While many producers doubt that subzones will ever be formalized, as many as eight have been proposed to the Consorzio. In general, the side north of the Montalcino hill, whose town reaches above 550 meters in elevation, is susceptible to frost and has proven more challenging for viticulture. Some producers, however, anticipating the effects of climate change, have recently shown greater enthusiasm for northern vineyards. Wines grown nearer to Montalcino itself, in the DOCG’s oldest soils, are praised for their elegance, while wines from the warm, southern end of the appellation can achieve the most ripeness and power.

Brunello is famously taught to be harvested from Sangiovese Grosso, a larger-berried, thick-skinned set of Sangiovese biotypes. Such clones—for example the B-BS11, isolated at Biondi Santi—have historically provided the backbone for Brunello wines. However, the disciplinare authorizes all Sangiovese clones, and contemporary Montalcino vineyards make use of an assortment of them, including the CCL 2000 suite. By law, Brunello di Montalcino, as well as Rosso di Montalcino, must be composed entirely of Sangiovese.

Montalcino lays claim to mandating the longest minimum maturation periods of any dry, nonfortified wine in the world, including such famously long-aged wines as Rioja Gran Reserva. The requirements are as follows:

Producers working in the most traditional style will age their wines in large Slavonian-oak botti, but those taking a contemporary approach might choose French, often new, barriques. While Riserva wines are undoubtedly more expensive than their Annata (annata meaning “year” and referencing basic Brunello di Montalcino) counterparts, some criticize the category of being overly oxidative and not necessarily higher in quality than regular Brunello. Several winegrowers have become increasingly conscientious of oxidation for both Brunello and Riserva wines, taking measures to improve longevity, such as harvesting earlier to preserve acidity and practicing more reductive handling throughout vinification.

A separate DOC exists for Rosso di Montalcino, which provides producers an opportunity to bottle younger Sangiovese wines. Wines can be released as early as September 1 of the year following harvest, allowing for a more vibrant, fresher wine intended for earlier consumption. Many producers will relegate their youngest or lowest-performing vines to their Rosso programs, but others are more stalwart in pursuing a distinctive character for quality Rosso wines. While Rosso is considered the entry-level wine in a Montalcino winery’s portfolio, the volume of Rosso production is actually lower than that of Brunello. Approximately 4.5 million bottles of Rosso di Montalcino are bottled annually, compared with 8 million bottles of Brunello and 1 million of Riserva.

Montalcino’s wine quality pyramid (Credit: Brandon Lee Wise)

In addition to Rosso and Brunello, Montalcino also forms a portion of Chianti Colli Senesi, while two separate DOCs, Moscadello di Montalcino and Sant’Antimo, follow the same boundaries as Brunello. Moscadello di Montalcino offers the present-day incarnation of the wine that brought Montalcino its initial renown, before being supplanted by Sangiovese. Moscadello is vinified from a clone of Moscato Bianco (Muscat Blanc à Petits Grains), believed to be autochthonous to the area, though some continue to debate if what is grown today is the same as what was cultivated in the 19^th century. Although the historic Moscadello di Montalcino wines were sparkling, today’s Moscadello wines can also be late harvest (or often made using appassimento techniques) as well as still. Only Il Poggione currently makes a sparkling Moscadello, produced using the Charmat method. Production of Moscadello di Montalcino remains small, and Biondi Santi, whose Moscadellos were once prized, harvested its final vintage in 1969. 

Sant’Antimo was created in 1996 as a reaction to the success of Super Tuscan wines. It takes its name from the Benedictine monastery in the southern end of the appellation. Sant’Antimo offers much looser regulations than Brunello di Montalcino, allowing, most consequentially, the inclusion of French grape varieties. The DOC has achieved little market recognition, and hectarage deeded to Sant’Antimo dwindled from 900 to 450 between 2008 and 2011 alone. Producers who wish to make more internationally styled wines from French varieties are more likely to label them as Toscana IGT, seeking to harness the greater brand power of Tuscany. 

Montepulciano

As the name of its top wine, Vino Nobile, suggests, Montepulciano has a winegrowing history that is illustrious as well as ancient. In his History of Rome, Livy cites Gallic interest in the Etruscan settlement that is today Montepulciano. Eight centuries later, in 789 CE, documentation specifies vineyards in the area, while a source dating back to 1350 details the trade and export of Montepulciano wine. Precisely when the town’s wine was granted the epithet Vino Nobile is unspecified, but in the 16^th century, Sante Lancerio, wine steward to Pope Paul III, wrote of the Roman bishop’s favor toward Montepulciano. In 1685, Francesco Redi, in his Bacchus in Tuscany, further dubbed Montepulciano’s output the “the king of all wines.”

Montepulciano’s wine quality pyramid (Credit: Brandon Lee Wise)

Despite admiration for Montepulciano’s wines during medieval and Renaissance times, by the early 20^th century, the area’s brand recognition had faded, and its reputation suffered in the shadows of Chianti and Montalcino. In the 1920s, wineries such as Fanetti pushed to modernize Montepulciano’s industry, but the ensuing decades were dominated by cooperative winemaking, with most local production dedicated to Chianti rather than Vino Nobile. It was not until the 1980s, with the efforts of such producers as Avignonesi and Poliziano—names that continue to lead the appellation—that a revival of Vino Nobile began. Investment followed from major Italian names, including Ruffino and Antinori, while a series of quality-driven small producers harvested their first vintages around the same time. Planted hectarage dedicated to Vino Nobile has more than doubled, from 615 hectares in 1980 to 1,300 hectares in 2013. Vino Nobile di Montepulciano was granted early DOC status in 1966 and elevated to DOCG in 1980.

Like Montalcino, Montepulciano occupies a single commune of the same name in the province of Siena. It lies just northeast of Montalcino, near Tuscany’s border with Umbria. The production zone is noncontiguous, with the Val di Chiana separating the largest vineyard area and the town of Montepulciano from a smaller eastern sector. The DOCG reaches its highest elevations, above 500 meters, toward its western extreme, though plantings are most concentrated near the center of the denomination. The temperature in Montepulciano is slightly lower than it is in Montalcino, and there is less of a maritime influence, though the commune does receive higher rainfall.

Montepulciano also fits within the boundaries of the Chianti Colli Senesi subzone, and its wine quality ladder is structured similarly to that of Montalcino. The youngest wines are bottled as Rosso di Montepulciano, itself a separate DOC. Aging requirements in Montepulciano are as follows:

Rosso, Vino Nobile, and Riserva each demand a minimum 70% Sangiovese, given the local moniker Prugnolo Gentile. As in Chianti and Chianti Classico, authorized Tuscan grapes account for the remainder. Although white varieties, such as Malvasia Bianca Lunga and Trebbiano Toscano, are permitted for up to 5% of a blend, quality producers will rarely include them. (White varieties do, however, have a dominant role in Montepulciano’s revered vin santo wines.) While often disregarded as the more rustic sibling to Chianti Classico and Brunello, top Vino Nobile merits consideration among the finest expressions of Sangiovese. Stylistically, Vino Nobile is often riper and less acidic than Chianti Classico, and a bit more angular than Brunello di Montalcino, especially in blended wines, but less oxidative.

Vin Santo

In addition to their red wines, Chianti, Chianti Classico, and Montepulciano, as well as Carmignano, all have separate DOCs for vin santo. Furthermore, vin santo is mentioned as a permitted wine style within a great deal of other Tuscan and Italian denominations. With the potential exception of Marsala, vin santo is Italy’s most famous dessert wine. Its origins lie in the Middle Ages with the flood of passito-style wines on the Italian Peninsula that followed the technique’s rediscovery during the Crusades. The etymology of vin santo has been cause for debate. Translated from Italian, it means “holy wine,” a potential reference to the wine’s role during Communion. It is more likely, however, that the name derives from Vino Santorini, a reference to the Greek vinsanto, crafted using similar methods.

Tuscan vin santo spent centuries outside commercial production. Sharecroppers were traditionally allowed to produce a small amount of vin santo each vintage, which they would store in the attics of their homes in an estate’s outbuildings. Vin santo was poured at special occasions or as a gesture to welcome guests. It was not until the latter half of the 20^th century that Tuscan wineries bottled any meaningful amount of vin santo for sale. In 2006, production of Vin Santo del Chianti Classico almost doubled, as a result of white grapes being banned from the Chianti Classico blend. While many of those white vines have inevitably been uprooted or grafted over to Sangiovese, some producers have seized the opportunity as a means to bolster their vin santo program.

Tuscan vin santo is most traditionally a blend of Trebbiano Toscano and Malvasia Bianca Lunga. Whereas Trebbiano is more acidic, Malvasia provides richness to the vin santo blend, as well as aromatic complexity. Sangiovese, which might also be blended into some vin santo wines, is the predominant grape in Occhio di Pernice, which means “eye of the partridge,” a reference to the reddish hue of this rare subcategory.

Following harvest, clusters are left to desiccate in a drying room, or appassitoio. Typically, these rooms are on the upper story or in the attic of an outbuilding, with open windows on opposite walls to maximize ventilation. As with a Sherry bodega, the terroir of the appossitoio and the character of the extended drying season are said to contribute to the expression of any given vin santo. While indoors, grapes remain vulnerable to rot during the post-harvest period. Winemakers have various options for the specific mechanism used to dry the grapes. For top-quality vin santo production, the most common tactic is either hanging garlands of the clusters vertically or laying them on bamboo shelves. Hypothetically, stringing the bunches is preferential, as it allows for 360 degrees of exposure. Bamboo shelves, however, avoid the toll of gravity on the bunches and permit some aeration from beneath through the spacing of the reeds.  

The duration of drying is a key indicator of vin santo style. While minimum requirements vary based on the appellation—Vin Santo di Montepulciano, for example, necessitates that clusters remain in the appassitoio until December 1 for standard vin santo, and January 1 for Riserva and Occhio di Pernice—some producers will exceed regulations by several months, leaving the grapes to dry until as late as early spring. Heavily shriveled by this time, the grapes are traditionally pressed using small basket presses. 

The must is then transferred into caratelli, small barrels historically 50 liters in size. The type of wood varies broadly and can include acacia, cherry, peach, mulberry, or mixed-stave barrels, but the most traditional is chestnut. Juniper has been widely abandoned due to the astringency it can impart on the wines. Wineries take pride in the age of their caratelli, which can be nearly 100 years old. As these vessels deteriorate, they are often replaced by oak barrels. The preferred cooperage for caratelli is Renzi Francesco, better known for the manufacture of similar barrels used for Modena balsamic vinegar.

In another parallel to balsamic production, each caratello holds a madre (mother). This sludgy mass of yeast and old wine is employed to induce fermentation and remains at the bottom of the caratello between fills. Some wineries can trace the origins of their madre back several generations. Once filled with the new must, caratelli are traditionally sealed with wax for the duration of the vin santo’s maturation. Winemaking then remains almost entirely hands off until bottling, and vin santo producers will cite dramatic differences in character between adjacent caratelli, as well as high evaporation, enhancing the category’s oxidative profile. The duration spent in wood will vary based on producer and appellation requirements. Vin Santo di Montepulciano demands three years of wood maturation, increased to five for Riserva and six for Occhio di Pernice. Many producers will far exceed the minimums presented by their denominations.

Vin santo production (Credit: Brandon Lee Wise)

Vin santo can demonstrate a tremendous degree of diversity. Wines that undergo a longer period of drying and maturation will show more richness and viscosity, while vin santi that are made according to the minimum requirements taste fresher. Volatile acidity is often high, and the wines will display oxidative, sometimes Sherry-like characters. Occhio di pernice wines might appear a couple shades darker than white vin santi and will express nuanced herbaceous, tobacco-like flavors. Sweetness levels vary widely, from relatively dry examples to those that can easily exceed 250 grams per liter of residual sugar. Vin santo is traditionally enjoyed with cantucci, small biscotti-like cookies that can be dunked into the wine. 

San Gimignano

Just west of Chianti Classico, the township of San Gimignano, whose medieval skyline is recognized for its gravity-defying tower houses, and its surroundings are home to Tuscany’s most famous white wine: Vernaccia di San Gimignano DOCG. A staple in the royal courts of Europe during the Middle Ages, San Gimignano’s historic liqueur-like wine has purportedly included such illustrious fans as Dante, Giovanni Boccaccio, and Franco Sacchetti (though the occasionally nebulous documentation of simply Vernaccia obscures the precise wines they exalted). Vernaccia’s cultivation in the vicinity is well documented from the 13^th century through the late Renaissance, with vineyards planted at most of the noble estates and the variety reaching its peak of popularity in the 1600s. The following two centuries, however, brought a period of decline, as consumers were drawn toward new, foreign beverages, such as coffee, tea, and other options for alcohol. Revival first began in the 1930s, when agricultural professor Carlo Fregola sought to repopulate the area with Vernaccia, though his efforts were halted with the onset of World War II. Vernaccia di San Gimignano was awarded Italy’s first DOC in 1966, elevated to DOCG in 1993.

San Gimignano’s vineyards are planted between 200 and 400 meters in elevation, on a series of hills. Soils consist mostly of sandy-clay yellow tuff, loose in structure and with high drainage. As mentioned, the variety Vernaccia di San Gimignano is unrelated to the other grapes with Vernaccia in their names, and today it is made into a dry wine, in contrast to its historical use in sweet wine production. It must account for a minimum of 85% of the DOCG blend, with the remainder coming from nonaromatic accessory varieties. Vernaccia di San Gimignano is typically a somewhat neutral wine, with orchard fruit flavors and a subtly bitter marzipan character. Critics have long decried the wine as less interesting than the town that grows it, but fine examples can be found, with higher quality consistently achieved within the past several years. Vernaccia di San Gimignano can exhibit a semioxidative quality, more prominent in the Riserva wines that often spend time in oak. Vernaccia shows an affinity for wood, taking well to a fuller body and nuanced barrel flavors, though heavy-handed use of oak can dull many Vernaccia wines. San Gimignano DOC allows for Sangiovese-based red and rosato wines as well as vin santo.

Bolgheri and Maremma

While many of Tuscany’s regions have millennia of winegrowing history, the coastal area has found viticultural prominence only since the second half of the 20^th century. Bolgheri and the broader Maremma have expanded rapidly within the past handful of decades, marrying Tuscany’s rich wine heritage with a New World ethos. 

The notion of producing fine wine, and in particular from Bordeaux varieties, on the Tuscan Coast is attributed most importantly to Marchese Mario Incisa della Rocchetta. Upon marrying Marchesa Clarice della Gherardesca, a member of the Tuscan nobility, the Piemontese Mario Incisa moved to Tenuta San Guido, a 3,000-hectacre property owned by his wife’s family and included in her dowry. A Bordeaux enthusiast, he planted his first Cabernet Sauvignon vines on the property in 1944, after noting a gravelly soil structure similar to that of Bordeaux’s Left Bank. Though he began as a hobbyist, Mario Incisa harvested his first commercial vintage of Sassicaia, meaning “place of many stones,” in 1968. In the 1970s, winemaker Giacomo Tachis, who already worked further inland for Gherardesca’s cousins, the Antinoris, was hired and introduced the permanent Sassicaia blend, which includes approximately 85% Cabernet Sauvignon, with Cabernet Franc accounting for the balance.

Sassicaia’s profound critical and commercial success quickly drew a slew of distinguished neighbors, including Meletti Cavallari in 1977 with Grattamacco, a Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and Sangiovese blend; Lodovico Antinori, whose Cabernet-focused Ornellaia saw its first vintage in 1985, followed by his Merlot, Masseto; Piero Antinori, who heads the Antinori portfolio, with Guado al Tasso, first harvested in 1990; and Barbaresco icon Angelo Gaja, who purchased his Ca’ Marcanda property in 1996. In those same years, smaller ventures, such as Le Macchiole and Tua Rita, also produced their inaugural vintages. The earliest of these wines, eventually dubbed Super Tuscans, were labeled as Vino da Tavola, as they were cultivated outside any established DOC region. But the labeling seemed contradictory to both the quality and price of the wines. Bolgheri subsequently achieved DOC status in 1984. Bolgheri Sassicaia, which encompasses a portion of Tenuta San Guido, was named an official Bolgheri subzone in 1994 and elevated to its own monopole DOC in 2013.

Bolgheri sits in the Livorno province, within the commune of Castagneto Carducci. Overall planting is still relatively low, with a total of 1,370 hectares under vine. The DOC is backdropped by craggy slopes, foothills of the Colline Metallifere, that run from the towns of Bibbona to Donoratico and barricade the landscape from harsh winter winds directed from the interior. While many prestige vineyards are planted on these high-elevation sites—the original Sassicaia vineyard, for example, is highest at 400 meters—others are on the sandy plains, which separate the mountains from the Mediterranean. The sea provides moderating breezes that help slow ripening, as do the Cecina and Cornia Rivers, to the north and south of the appellation, respectively. The water reflects sunlight, contributing to Bolgheri’s intense luminosity. 

Bolgheri’s geology is heterogeneous. Tenuta San Guido holds ancient marine deposits of rounded stones and is rich in limestone. Masseto, by contrast, is famously cultivated in blue clay, which, despite its high holding capacity, releases water slowly, according to winemaker Axel Heinz. Portions of Bolgheri contain more volcanic material, and the flatter lands have a sandier structure and often reddish hue. On average, vineyards are planted at approximately 7,000 vines per hectare but can reach as high as 10,000, as is common in Bordeaux.

Cabernet Sauvignon remains Bolgheri’s most cultivated variety, covering 37% of the vineyard area. It is followed by Merlot at 23% and Cabernet Franc at 12%, as well as Syrah, Petit Verdot, and Sangiovese in smaller quantities. Among whites, Vermentino is given the most hectarage, and some producers also champion Sauvignon Blanc, Viognier, and Chardonnay. Monovarietal Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, and Merlot are permitted, though Sangiovese and Syrah cannot contribute more than 50% of a red blend. White Bolgheri wines can be blended from multiple varieties: Vermentino, Sauvignon Blanc, and, Viognier from 0-100%, with an allowable 40% of other white-grape varieties suitable for cultivation in Tuscany. Given these restrictions, among others, several IGT wines continue to be bottled within Bolgheri’s boundaries. A Bolgheri Superiore category also exists for wines aged two years prior to release, with at least one year in oak.

The state-of-the-art cellar at Masseto (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak)

Winemaking in Bolgheri adheres to what many consider a more international style, not only due to the preeminence of French varieties, but also the use of meticulous new technologies. Vinification is often very precise, with high investment in expensive equipment, such as optical sorters, customized fermentation vessels, and new barriques. Stylistically, the wines might be considered a midway point between the classicism of Bordeaux and the opulence of Napa Valley.

Val di Cornia DOC and Suvereto DOCG form a natural extension of Bolgheri to the south. Suvereto occupies the higher ground, and producers here may bottle varietally labeled Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Merlot—which is considered especially successful. Suvereto was a subzone of Val di Cornia until its upgrade in 2011. In that same year, Val di Cornia was given its own separate DOCG, Rosso della Val di Cornia. The region follows the path of the Cornia River and has seen recent activity as winegrowers are regularly priced out of Bolgheri. The DOCG is specific to reds based on Sangiovese (a minimum 40%), while the DOC allows for a number of styles. 

The rest of the southern Tuscan Coast, including the small island of Giglio, is occupied by Maremma DOC. While the appellation lies in the Grosseto province, the Maremma refers to a larger stretch of land, running along the shorelines of Tuscany and Lazio. Historically, the Maremma was swampland—malaria prone and unsuitable to viticulture—until Mussolini ordered its drainage in the 1930s. Covering a large area, Maremma DOC has varied geography and geology, ranging from flatter, clay-dominant coastal areas, to the Volsini mountain range and its surrounding tufacious soils, to Mount Amiata, a lava dome further inland.   

Almost every wine style imaginable is vinified in the Maremma. While early efforts focused on native Italian grapes, such as Ansonica, Canaiolo, Sangiovese, Aleatico, and Ciliegiolo, the area shifted to include more French varieties in the 1990s. Both continue to be made, with Vermentino in particular a source of exciting wines recently. (Vermentino also finds success north of the Maremma, in such DOCs as San Torpè, Candia dei Colli Apuani, and Colli di Luni, as the Tuscan Coast approaches Liguria, a classic region for the variety.) But Maremma DOC largely operates as a catchall denomination, and several additional DOC/Gs are carved from within its boundaries. Monteregio di Massa Marittima fills much of the Maremma’s northern sector near the Colline Metallifere. Moving southeast, Montecucco DOC and Montecucco Sangiovese DOCG surround the western edges of Montalcino, and several important wineries from the neighboring appellation have invested in Montecucco to produce more affordable Sangiovese wines. The DOCG is devoted exclusively to the variety, with Sangiovese providing a minimum 90% of the blend. The DOC is more forgiving, lowering the required portion of Sangiovese to 60% and permitting white wines from Trebbiano Toscano, Vermentino, and other varieties. Like Montalcino, Montecucco extends across a series of gentle hills, but, in the shadow of Mount Amiata, it contains minimal calcareous soil.

The southern Maremma is dominated by Morellino di Scansano DOCG. The area is similarly focused on Sangiovese—or Morellino, as the variety is known locally—which must compose a minimum 85% of the blend. Believed to date back to the Etruscans, the tradition of viticulture here is older than it is in many other places in the Maremma. Planted mainly on hillsides up to 450 meters in elevation, Morellino di Scansano is barricaded from cold northern winds. Its soils transition from predominately sandstone in the west, where the wines are fuller, to more clay-limestone content toward the east, where the wines are more structured and elegant. A Riserva category requires additional aging, including at least one year in oak. Perhaps the most famous wine from the area, however, is Fattoria Le Pupille’s Saffredi, an IGT blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. White wines based on Trebbiano Toscano are made in the overlapping Bianco di Pitigliano DOC, which extends to the Lazio border, encompassing the Sovana DOC, where Sangiovese, Aleatico, Ciliegiolo, Merlot, and Cabernet Sauvignon are the focus. To the west, on the small Argentario Peninsula and the island of Giglio, the Ansonica Costa dell’Argentario DOC is dedicated to Ansonica (also known as Inzolia in Sicily). Ansonica offers white wines of diminished acidity, fuller body, ripe yellow orchard fruit flavors, and, in some examples, tannic grip.

Other Regions

A few additional appellations of note are scattered across Tuscany. On the opposite side of Florence, northwest of Chianti Classico, is the small, low-lying Carmignano DOCG. Carmignano shares with Chianti several centuries’ worth of documented praise for its red wines, its boundaries also formalized by Cosimo III de’ Medici in his 1716 edict. Once a part of Chianti Montalbano, Carmignano earned separate DOC status in 1975 (and DOCG in 1990), largely because of the efforts of Ugo Contini Bonacossi of Capezzana, who planted his vineyard partly to Cabernet Sauvignon cuttings from Château Lafite-Rothschild. Carmignano has a long history with Cabernet Sauvignon, with the first vines purportedly arriving in the 16^th century at the behest of Catherine de’ Medici, who served as queen of France. The DOCG requires that Cabernet, either Sauvignon or Franc, account for 10 to 20% of any wine. Sangiovese, however, must contribute a minimum of 50%. The wines must be aged for at least 8 months in oak or chestnut, while Riserva wines require 12 months as well as additional time prior to release. Younger wines are released under the corresponding Barco Reale di Carmignano DOC.

East of Montepulciano, Cortona DOC is peculiar in its focus on Syrah. The Rhône variety fills a miminum 50% of Cortona blends simply labeled Rosso, joined by at least 10 to 20% Merlot. While Syrah’s history in Cortona might begin in the early 20^th century, when the Count of Montecarlo di Lucca supposedly brought vine material back from France, contemporary interest resulted from a study by Professor Attilio Scienza and the University of Milan in the 1970s. Scienza planted an experimental vineyard, including a number of Syrah clones, inspired by the climatic similarities between the Cortona area and the Rhône Valley. Syrah accounts for 80% of Cortona’s production, though varietally labeled examples of Chardonnay, Grechetto, Sauvignon Blanc, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and Sangiovese are also allowed.

Vineyard on the coast of Elba (Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Cortona is bounded on most sides by Valdichiana DOC, which occupies the Chiana Valley south of Arezzo. First established in 1972 as Bianco Vergine Valdichiana, it became Valdichiana in 2011, when the disciplinare was updated to include red wines, requiring a minimum of 50% Sangiovese. To the north, the Val d’Arno di Sopra DOC (also Valdarno di Sopra) was established in 2011, despite the fact that Cosimo III de’Medici had also declared its boundaries. Val d’Arno di Sopra’s wines are harvested near the banks of the Arno River and the surrounding area. While many still, sparkling, and sweet styles of every shade are permitted, attention is given to French varieties. Petrolo’s Galatrona, a Merlot, is one of the area’s most recognizable wines.

Off the coast and near Bolgheri, the island of Elba bottles some of Tuscany’s most distinctive wines. The Elba DOC covers the entire island, as does Elba Aleatico Passito DOCG, established for its sweet, red, dried-grape wine. Elba’s long history of winegrowing in iron-rich soils is documented by Pliny the Elder. The island’s advocates have included Cosimo III de’ Medici and Napoleon Bonaparte, who became familiar with Elba’s wines during his banishment there. Though once an important contributor to Elba’s economy, viticulture has declined in the past century because of the encroachment of property development and tourism as well as the exodus of critical laborers to the mainland. Yet grapegrowing persists, with most vineyards today dedicated to white varieties. Some notable Ansonica is made, while Trebbiano Toscano, Vermentino, and Moscato may also lead white blends; red wines under Elba DOC contain a minimum 60% Sangiovese. Elba produces some of the finest expressions of Aleatico, a grape believed native to Tuscany. For Elba Aleatico Passito DOCG, producers choose whether to dry the Aleatico bunches in the sun or shade, some opting for the latter to maintain freshness. In either case, drying must continue for a minimum of 10 days. The wine ferments on the skins before aging in either stainless steel or wooden vessels. The resulting wines show fine, dusty tannins and boisterous flavors of dried black fruits, exotic spices, and potpourri.

Umbria

The landlocked region of Umbria is located in the Apennines between Tuscany, Lazio, and the Marche. Cutting through the center of the region, the River Tiber flows past the Umbrian capital Perugia, then travels south to Rome. Before Roman absorption, the area was inhabited by the Umbri people; later, it was remembered as the birthplace of Saint Francis, founder of the Franciscan order, in Assisi. Umbria carries a rich agricultural heritage—recognized for its olive oil, saffron, and cereal grains—though widespread commercial winegrowing didn’t take hold until the latter half of the 20^th century. The majority of Umbrian wine is still bottled as Orvieto, but its reds, most notably Sagrantino, continue to garner praise. 

Orvieto

Archaeological evidence of ancient Etruscan winemaking suggests a long history of viticulture in Orvieto DOC. The appellation takes its name from the fortified hilltop town at its center, visited for its magnificent 14^th-century cathedral, whose completion was supposedly largely paid for with revenue earned by the local wine industry. For most of its existence, Orvieto has been made as a sweet wine, though a transition toward drier styles is noted from the 1800s. The boundaries of Orvieto were first delimited in 1931, but for much of the 20^th century, the region was known for its innocuous wines, which were often transported in bulk across the border to Tuscany for bottling. In more recent decades, the quality of this Italian white has improved, especially through more stringent viticultural efforts, codified in 1997 with the introduction of the Orvieto Superiore category.

The hilltop town of Orvieto (Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

Orvieto is nestled into the southwestern edge of Umbria, with a small portion bleeding into Lazio. The best wines come mostly from the Orvieto Classico subzone, surrounding the town, though it encompasses roughly half of the entire DOC. Tufa soils, similar to those found in Vouvray, cover the region, and the Classico subzone has a particularly high tufaceous concentration. The dammed Lago di Corbara is found near Orvieto’s eastern extreme, where fog encourages the development of noble rot, beneficial to the few remaining sweet wines made there. (The Lago di Corbara DOC crosses into Orvieto and allows for white, red, and passito styles from both native and international varieties.) 

Grechetto di Orvieto and Grechetto di Todi (Pignoletto) are two discrete varieties, and both are usually blended for the wines of Orvieto. Together with Trebbiano Procanico, a superior biotype of Trebbiano Toscano, these grapes constitute a minimum 60% of the cuvée. The balance can come from Verdello, Drupeggio, or other local cultivars, in addition to certain international varieties, whose role has fortunately decreased in recent times. Orvieto is often a charming yet simple wine, with notes of lemon blossoms and white flowers, designed for early drinking. Better examples deliver more complexity, with a chalkier texture and the ability to mature for a few years. Rosso Orvietano, a separate DOC, allows for red wines from various Italian and French varieties.

Montefalco, Torgiano, and Other Regions

Despite Orvieto’s prominence, the most celebrated wines of Umbria hail from the Montefalco region, home to the Sagrantino variety, in the province of Perugia. The Sagrantino di Montefalco appellation was upgraded to DOCG status in 1992 and has attracted sizable investment from leading Italian firms outside Umbria. Winegrowing is documented in the area for at least a millennium, but for much of Montefalco’s history, production was focused on sweet passito wines, which, while rarer, are still bottled today. Beginning in the 1970s, producer Arnaldo Caprai pioneered a transition toward dry wines as well as a series of vineyard advancements, such as a shift toward Guyot training, to create wines in a more contemporary style. 

The boundaries of Montefalco Sagrantino DOCG follow the fluvial deposits formed by the Bastardo Basin some two million years ago. Backdropped by the Martani mountain range, a subset of the Apennines, Montefalco has a combination of fluvial and alluvial clay soils with high calcareous content. The region spans five communes: Montefalco, Bevagna, Gualdo Cattaneo, Castel Ritaldi, and Giano dell’Umbria. Montefalco and Bevagna yield the most serious wines. Examples from the hilltop township of Montefalco are more stoic, while Bevagna’s are more floral and elegant. Winters here are cold, though summers mild, and Sagrantino seems to perform best with elevated rainfall.   

Due to Sagrantino’s aggressive polyphenolic content, tannin management is a primary concern during vinification. The appassimento process helps break down tannin, which not only assists in the profile of Sagrantino’s passito wines but also encourages some winemakers to include a percentage of dehydrated clusters in their dry wines. However, even with considerable cellar age, Sagrantino maintains its tannic intensity. Subtly fragrant, and at times showing ripe black fruit flavors, Sagrantino is distinguished by an intense piney herbaceousness that can polarize consumers. 

Within the same borders, Montefalco DOC allows for more accessible, though still commendable, red wines, which are based on Sangiovese and include a minimum 10 to 25% Sagrantino. Montefalco’s white wines are made primarily from the two Grechettos, as are those of the nested Todi and Colli Martani DOCs (both of which also permit reds), whereas the small, overlapping Spoleto DOC promotes the little-known variety Trebbiano Spoletino, distinct from Trebbiano Toscano. Trebbiano Spoletino can yield a wide range of expressions, from lighter, more tart bottlings to examples with elevated alcohol and floral aromatics. 

Though less fashionable today, Torgiano, including both the diminutive Torgiano DOC and Torgiano Rosso Riserva DOCG, was heralded as Umbria’s quintessential red wine until it was surpassed by Montefalco Sagrantino in the late 20^th century. In 1968, Torgiano became one of the earliest DOC regions. A DOCG for dry reds, Torgiano Rosso Riserva, was established in 1990. For decades, it was dominated by the Lungarotti family, which was eager to demonstrate Sangiovese’s potential outside Tuscany in its benchmark wine, Rubesco. The DOCG mandates a minimum of 70% Sangiovese, while the DOC is much more flexible, allowing for sweet, sparking, red, white, and rosato wines, including varietally labeled Chardonnay, Riesling, Pinot Grigio, Pinot Nero, Merlot, and Cabernet Sauvignon. Similar to Montefalco, Torgiano has mainly clay-sand fluvial soils.

Emilia-Romagna

Considered the breadbasket of Italy, Emilia-Romagna has a distinguished food culture that includes such globally revered products as Prosciutto di Parma, Parmigiano-Reggiano, and Modena balsamic vinegar. Food lovers pilgrimage to the cities of Reggio Emilia and Modena, the latter housing chef Massimo Bottura’s famed Osteria Francescana, which topped the list of the World’s 50 Best Restaurants in both 2016 and 2018. Bottura is credited with reimagining the convergence of traditional Italian cooking with molecular gastronomy. 

An acetaia in Reggio Emilia (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak)

Emilia-Romagna’s contributions to Italy extend well beyond cuisine. The University of Bologna, in the regional capital, is the world’s oldest university, founded in 1088. Luxury automobile manufacturers Ferrari, Lamborghini, Maserati, and Ducati are all headquartered in Emilia-Romagna, and the region is the birthplace of such defining musicians as Giuseppe Verdi, Arturo Toscanini, and Luciano Pavarotti.

Emilia-Romagna has never been greatly lauded for its wines. The Po River informs the northern border for a long stretch of the pendant-shaped region, which extends nearly the width of the Italian Peninsula. As a result, the upper portions of Emilia-Romagna, those in the Po River basin, are flatter and more fertile than typical Italian wine country—good for food crops but less so for viticulture. Emilia-Romagna, however, has made important strides in wine quality in the last several decades and remains the third largest region of wine production by volume. In the historic Romagna portion, to the southeastern corner of Emilia-Romagna, the quality of Sangiovese wines continues to improve, while the focus in Emilia is on sparkling wine, most famously the red Lambrusco. The natural-wine movement, with leaders such as La Stoppa, has also gained traction in Emilia-Romagna, reflected by the growth of metodo ancestrale wines as well as experimentation with French varieties.

Lambrusco

Lambrusco is neither a single grape nor a region. Instead, it can be thought of as a style of sparkling red wine that defines the image of Emilia. Regrettably, the category continues to elicit negative connotations among many wine consumers, largely due to Riunite, a brand of cloying red fizz, dominating American supermarket shelves in the late 20^th century. The cooperative winery, which advertised that its Lambrusco should be served on ice, was the top-selling import in the United States for much of the 1970s and ’80s, selling 11.5 million cases in the US in 1985, a record still unbroken. Yet an abundance of quality Lambrusco wines is made today, demonstrating the diversity of red sparkling wine.

Each Lambrusco cultivar finds greater concentration in specific DOCs. Several Emilia appellations allow for Lambrusco styles, including, from west to east, Colli di Parma DOC, Colli di Scandiano e di Canossa DOC, Reggiano DOC, and Modena DOC. The most famous wines, however, are from the varietally named DOCs of Lambrusco di Sorbara, Lambrusco Grasparossa di Castelvetro, and Lambrusco Salamino di Santa Croce, all near the city of Modena. Lambrusco Grasparossa di Castelvetro has the most challenging terroir. Hillier than the other appellations, with clay soils that have large limestone deposits, the land is difficult to farm, and, accordingly, some argue that it yields the finest Lambrusco wines. They are the most structured, dark, and tannic. Lambrusco di Sorbara DOC, by contrast, rests between the Secchia and Panaro Rivers, its vineyards planted atop a flatter, sandy floodplain. The lightest in both color and flavor, wines from Lambrusco di Sorbara offer finesse and brightness. The Lambrusco di Sorbara DOC mandates only a minimum of 60% of the variety Lambrusco di Sorbara because of its unique morphological challenges, with Lambrusco Salamino typically comprising the rest of the blend. Lambrusco Salamino di Santa Croce DOC is in the north of the Modena province. Its soils are similarly defined by flood patterns, and the region is mostly flat. Lambrusco Salamino wines might be considered a midpoint between Lambrusco di Sorbara and Grasparossa, though the variety is typically used for sweeter styles.

Mechanical harvesting is regularly practiced in the Lambrusco appellations. Lambrusco wines are generally produced using the Charmat method (some producers will also bottle historically minded metodo ancestrale Lambrusco wines), and both frizzante and spumante versions are made, though the former is more common. Depending on pressure, bottles will be sealed with either a standard or a mushroom cork. Lambrusco wines can be made red or rosato, as well as secco or asciutto (dry), semi-secco or abboccato (off-dry), amabile (gently sweet), or dolce (sweet). The wines are usually nonvintage, and, like producers of Prosecco, winemakers here will often perform multiple fermentations over the course of the year, so that the Lambrusco available on the market is as fresh as possible. Unfermented must is chilled in tank until a new batch is needed. 

The harvest in Lambrusco Grasparossa di Castelvetro (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak)

Other Regions 

Beyond Lambrusco, the Emilia half of Emilia-Romagna continues to excel with sparkling wine production. The Ortrugo dei Colli Piacentini DOC—itself within the larger and more flexible Colli Piacentini DOC, which spans a series of four valleys—spotlights the local white grape of the same name. While Ortrugo had historically served as a blending variety for Malvasia Bianca di Candia, Luigi Mossi began to experiment with varietal wines beginning in the 1970s. Both still and sparkling Ortrugo wines are bottled, in either case a crisp, somewhat restrained white wine. Sparkling versions resemble a stonier Prosecco. The small Gutturnio DOC approximately overlaps Ortrugo dei Colli Piacentini and is designated for still and sparkling wines produced from Barbera and Croatina (Bonarda).

Pignoletto offers an expression of the variety in central Emilia-Romagna that differs from that of Grechetto di Todi in Umbria. The Pignoletto DOC offers sparkling, still, and sweet styles, while Colli Bolognesi Classico Pignoletto DOCG focuses exclusively on dry white wines. (The larger Colli Bolognesi DOC includes a wider range of red and white wines from numerous grapes.) The wines are gently floral, with lemon, fresh apple, and white tea qualities. Another native white, Montù, is grown nearby in Reno DOC. The variety produces both sparkling and still wines that are high in acid, with floral and citrus notes.

Romagna, stretching east of Emilia to the Adriatic, is home to Italy’s first DOCG for white wine, Romagna Albana, awarded in 1987. An old variety with a long history of cultivation in Emilia-Romagna, Albana has been proven to share a parent-offspring dynamic with Garganega. Its morphological variability, however, suggests the possibility of multiple varieties sharing the name Albana. The finest examples are said to come from the clay-limestone soils in the township of Bertinoro, whose name translates to “drunk in gold.” According to legend, in the fifth century CE, the daughter of Emperor Theodosius was so enamored with the local wines that she suggested they be consumed in a golden vessel. Regardless of its level of sweetness, Albana can produce weighty, honeyed, and, in some examples, tannic white wines, in addition to simpler expressions. Many claim the variety reaches its highest expression as a dessert wine, either passito or botrytized, as several pockets of Romagna allow for the development of noble rot.

Additional white wines are made in the larger Romagna DOC, including those from the local varieties Pagadebit (or Bombino Bianco) and Trebbiano Romagnolo, a common grape distinct from, and considered more interesting than, Trebbiano Toscano, with which it is often interplanted. Terrano, here called Cagnina, offers Lambrusco-like off-dry sparkling red wines. Romagna’s most significant red wines, however, are made from Sangiovese. Though long thought of as either anemic or, by contrast, overly oaked, and altogether unremarkable when compared with its Tuscan counterparts, Romagna Sangiovese has made recent strides in public opinion. The Convito di Romagna bands together eight like-minded producers, who impose stricter quality standards for themselves and their wines. The region has two predominant soils: the looser, limestone marls found at higher elevations yield more structured, savory Sangiovese wines, while the clay soils at lower sites provide fruitier examples. Romagna producers often compare their clones of Sangiovese to the historic Sangiovese Grosso biotypes of Montalcino. Several other appellations are carved from Romagna DOC, including, from west to east, Colli d’Imola DOC, Colli di Faenza DOC, Colli Romagna Centrale DOC, and Colli di Rimini DOC. The wines of Colli di Faenza in particular have gained attention, as have Sangiovese wines from old-vine material in the township of Predappio. Though interpretations vary widely, the best Romagna Sangiovese wines are a few shades richer than the typical Tuscan bottling.

North of Romagna DOC, the Bosco Eliceo DOC borders the Adriatic, marked by old oak forest, as its name indicates, and a series of brackish estuaries of the Po River. This is home to Fortana, a red variety that behaves similarly to the Lambrusco family and is usually planted without grafting. Fortana wines, both still and sparkling, elicit a bright red berry character and spice.

The Marche

Marche, or Le Marche in Italian, refers to the March of Ancona, a medieval borderland that separated the Papal States from the northern city-states. Today, the Marche (or, simply, Marche) remains a transitional region between north-central Italy and the south that was once included in the Kingdom of Naples. But while the Marche shares the variety Montepulciano with the adjacent Abruzzo, its wines are otherwise quite distinct from those of its neighbors, including a selection of peculiar red wines as well as many of Italy’s finest whites, made from Verdicchio.

Verdicchio dei Castelli di Jesi and Verdicchio di Matelica

While the variety is authorized for a number of appellations in the Marche, Verdicchio reaches its apex of expression in the DOCG regions Castelli di Jesi Verdicchio Riserva and Verdicchio di Matelica Riserva and their corresponding DOCs. Some producers might use the DOC label to avoid certain aging requirements, and the DOC regions Verdicchio dei Castelli di Jesi and Verdicchio di Matelica are generally used for younger wines as well as sparkling and passito styles. Castelli di Jesi is the larger of the two, located in north-central Marche, just outside the town of Jesi, best known as the birthplace of Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II in 1194. The majority of the DOCG, which covers 3,000 hectares, is cultivated on a series of hills on the banks of the Esino River. Elevations stretch between 100 and 700 meters, though most vineyards sit toward the lower end of this range. Nested between and moderated by both the Adriatic Sea and the Apennines, Castelli di Jesi has a relatively warm climate, despite its susceptibility to spring frost.

Matelica is found southwest and further inland, with one-tenth of Castelli di Jesi’s hectarage. Wines are grown in the Alta Vallesina, a high valley with a rare north-south orientation, protected from the maritime influence experienced by Castelli di Jesi. Vineyards rest at an average 350 meters but reach as high as 720. Much of the vinescape is harvested from steep inclines, with complex, limestone-based soils. Verdicchio di Matelica wines typically show higher alcohol, higher acid, and more structure, as well as a distinct “mineral” quality, while Verdicchio dei Castelli di Jesi is softer and more fragrant. More subtle Verdicchio wines can be found, but overall quality in these two regions is high and among the best for Italian white wine regions. The finest examples from each demonstrate a capacity to age. More recently, some Marche producers have begun to experiment with metodo ancestrale Verdicchio wines as well as amphora aging. 

Other Regions 

In the Marche’s southeastern corner, Offida DOCG authorizes varietally labeled examples of Pecorino and Passerina, two native white grapes. The latter, which has gained popularity within the last decade, was first championed in Offida in the 1980s by Guido Cocci Grifoni, who is still regarded as the foremost interpreter of the variety. Pecorino wines are noted for their high acidity, matched by a generous body and, as the wines age, a certain dairy quality—fitting for the variety’s name. Varietal Pecorino—as well as white blends with Passerina and Trebbiano Toscano—is also made in Falerio DOC, which sits atop the Marche’s southern border. Passerina produces wines that are more chiseled and citrusy, and it can be made into sparkling and passito wines in the Terre di Offida DOC, which follows the same boundaries. The Offida region is on a gentle plateau, moderated by the Adriatic Sea, and grows warmer closer to the coast. Offida has predominately clay soils, which are well suited to Pecorino.

Offida DOCG also includes red wines, for which a minimum of 85% Montepulciano is mandated. The appellation is surrounded by the larger Rosso Piceno DOC, which spans the southeastern quadrant of the Marche, and whose Superiore subzone is similarly confined within Offida. Rosso Piceno also cultivates Montepulciano as well as Sangiovese, with the best examples from the nested Cònero DOCG, which surrounds the city of Ancona on the coast. These mountain vineyards have whitish limestone-heavy soils, yielding Montepulciano wines that are more tannic and austere than those grown further south in Abruzzo. Cònero Riserva wines require longer aging than those from Rosso Cònero, and while historically these wines have been criticized for the heavy-handed application of new oak, producers have recently sought more restrained examples.

Coastal village in the northern Marche (Photo credit: Adobe Stock)

North of Cònero and overlapping with Castelli di Jesi, Lacrima di Morro d’Alba DOC authorizes a variety that neared extinction in the last century. Several wines throughout Italy bear similar names, but here Lacrima, which means “tear,” likely refers to the variety’s droplet-shaped berries. The commune of Morro d’Alba should not be confused with Alba in Piedmont. Noted for their exuberant fragrance, Lacrima wines are commonly made using the governo method, long abandoned in other Italian fine-wine regions.

Further inland near Matelica, Vernaccia Nera is the primary grape in both Serrapetrona DOC and Vernaccia di Serrapetrona DOCG. The former produces dry red wines, noted for their aromatic lift. The DOCG yields an idiosyncratic red sparkling wine, which, unlike Lambrusco, is fermented from partially dried grapes (a minimum 40% of clusters) and undergoes secondary fermentation in bottle rather than tank. The resulting wines are robust and singular—best known as a sweet, dessert style, though dry examples can be found. Vernaccia Nera must not be mistaken for Vernaccia Rossa, which is a form of Aleatico cultivated in the tiny Pergola DOC. In addition to the DOC/G wines mentioned, it is not unusual for Marche winegrowers to bottle IGT wines made from French grape varieties, with Cabernet Franc and Merlot receiving the most attention.

Lazio

South of Tuscany and Umbria, along the Tyrrhenian Sea, Lazio, which contains the national capital of Rome, is also known as Latium, its Latin name. Despite this nod to antiquity, today’s Lazio is much larger in size than the historic region, crossing into land that would have been inhabited by the Etruscans. As a result, beyond the Eternal City, rural Lazio is somewhat culturally indistinct. Much of Lazio’s wine is sold in Roman restaurants and enjoyed locally. The wines that do reach a wider audience are generally the white Malvasia blends of Frascati, while the most important reds are made from Cesanese.

The hills of Rome as seen from the Vittoriano monument (Photo credit: Bryce Wiatrak)

Lazio is best recognized for its whites, with 26 of its 30 DOC/G appellations permitting white wine production. In most circumstances, these white blends call for some combination of Malvasia del Lazio (also called Malvasia Puntinata), Malvasia Bianca di Candia, Trebbiano Toscano, and Trebbiano Giallo, a separate variety with a longer history of cultivation in Lazio. In the north of the region, just west of the portion of Orvieto that spills across Lazio’s border, Est! Est!! Est!!! di Montefiascone garners greater attention for its exclamatory name than it does for the quality of its wines. According to legend, a medieval German bishop traveling to Rome sent an emissary in advance to scout out the taverns serving the best wine. He marked the doors of the qualifying establishments with the Latin word est, “it is,” and was purportedly so captivated with the wines of Montefiascone that he scrawled Est! Est!! Est!!! on its local inn.

More impressive today are the whites coming from further south. The catchall Roma DOC, with important marketing cachet, outlines a large swath of central Lazio surrounding the capital, while the smaller enclave of Castelli Romani DOC is found just outside the city, subdivided further into a series of tiny appellations. The best wines come from Frascati, which corresponds to three denominations with identical boundaries: Frascati Superiore DOCG, Cannellino di Frascati DOCG, and Frascati DOC. Grounded in the two Malvasias, Frascati Superiore wines may include up to 30% Bellone, a rare but promising grape variety that plays a more dominant role in the nearby Cori DOC. Frascati wines are marked by their ripe orchard fruit and herb flavors and tactile breadth. Malvasia del Lazio is also well suited to botrytized styles, and Cannellino di Frascati is reserved exclusively for late-harvest wines. Sparkling wines are permitted under Frascati DOC. Quality whites are also bottled next door in Marino DOC as well as Zagarolo DOC.

While some admirable wines are made from international varieties (the Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot wines of the winery Falesco, for example), the most distinctive reds in Lazio are made from Cesanese. In a cluster of appellations southeast of Rome, and within Roma DOC, what are believed to be two distinct varieties are cultivated: Cesanese Comune and Cesanese di Affile. The smaller-berried Cesanese di Affile is considered more complex but is less widespread because of its finicky behavior in the vineyard and preference for high-elevation sites. Cesanese Comune is more prevalent in the lower plains of Cesanese di Olevano DOC, while there is a greater concentration of Cesanese di Affile in the higher, more rugged Cesanese di Affile DOC and Cesanese del Piglio DOCG, the only DOCG in Lazio for red wine. Cesanese wines are characterized by ripe berry flavors, nuanced with notes of spice and red flowers, and a diminished tannin structure. Each of the three Cesanese appellations offers a Superiore or Riserva category, or both, which require longer aging prior to release.

Bibliography

Bastianich, Joseph, and David Lynch. Vino Italiano: The Regional Wines of Italy. New York: Clarkson Potter, 2005.

Belfrage, Nicolas. Brunello to Zibibbo: The Wines of Tuscany, Central and Southern Italy. London: Octopus Publishing Group, 2001. 

Belfrage, Nicolas. The Finest Wines of Tuscany and Central Italy. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2009.

“Brunello is the most expensive wine (1,085 euros per hectoliter), followed by Amarone and Barolo.” Wine News. January 13, 2020. https://winenews.it/en/brunello-is-the-most-expensive-wine-1085-euros-per-hectolitre-followed-by-amarone-and-barolo_407613.

Capalbo, Carla. “Italy’s heart, beating strong.” Decanter. February 2014. http://carlacapalbo.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/2014-Feb-Decanter-Emilia-Romagna-Carla-Capalbo.pdf.

D’Agata, Ian. Italy’s Native Wine Grape Terroirs. Oakland: University of California Press, 2019.

D’Agata, Ian. “Lazio: New Vintages, New Discoveries.” Vinous. June 18, 2019. https://vinous.com/articles/lazio-new-vintages-new-discoveries-jun-2019. 

D’Agata, Ian. Native Wine Grapes of Italy. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2014. 

D’Agata, Ian. “New Releases from the Marche: Something for Everyone.” Vinous. July 2015. https://vinous.com/articles/new-releases-from-the-marche-something-for-everyone-jul-2015.

D’Agata, Ian. “Umbria – New Releases.” Vinous. June 2016. https://vinous.com/articles/umbria-new-releases-jun-2016.

Geller, Martinne. “Banfi’s new guard wants to thaw Riunite wine image.” Reuters. April 19, 2012. https://www.reuters.com/article/banfi/banfis-new-guard-wants-to-thaw-riunite-wine-image-idUSL2E8FIMA020120419.

Goode, Jamie. “Visiting Chianti Classico Part 1: Introduction.” Wine Anorak. Accessed October 22, 2020. http://www.wineanorak.com/italy/ChiantiClassico1_introduction.htm.

Johnson, Hugh, and Jancis Robinson, eds. The World Atlas of Wine. 8th ed. London: Mitchell Beazley, 2019. 

Kim, Stevie. Italian Wine Unplugged: Grape by Grape. Italy: Positive Press, 2017.

Lukacs, Paul. Inventing Wine: A New History of One of the World’s Most Ancient Pleasures. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2012. 

Masnaghetti, Alessandro. Bolgheri e Bolgheri Sassicaia: Le Vigne e le Cantine. 3rd ed. Monza, Italy: I Cru di Enogea, 2019.

Masnaghetti, Alessandro. Chianti Classico: Vigneti e Zone di Produzione. 3rd ed. Monza, Italy: I Cru di Enogea, 2018.

Masnaghetti, Alessandro. Vino Nobile di Montepulciano: Le Vigne e le Cantine. Monza, Italy: I Cru di Enogea, 2015.

Nesto, Bill, and Frances Di Savino. Chianti Classico: The Search for Tuscany’s Noblest Wine. Oakland: University of California Press, 2016.

O’Keefe, Kerin. Brunello di Montalcino: Understanding and Appreciating One of Italy’s Greatest Wines. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2012. 

Robinson, Jancis, ed. The Oxford Companion to Wine. 4th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015. 

Robinson, Jancis, Julia Harding, and José Vouillamoz. Wine Grapes. New York: Harper Collins, 2012.

Solieri, Laura, Lisa Solieri, and Paolo Giudici. Vinegars of the World. Milan: Springer, 2009.

“Vino Nobile: 21st Century Renaissance.” Wine Enthusiast. March 29, 2017. https://www.winemag.com/2017/03/29/vino-nobile-21st-century-renaissance. 

Wiatrak, Bryce. “Sangiovese on Edge: Tumult & Triumph in Chianti Classico & Montalcino.” GuildSomm. June 26, 2020. https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/bryce-wiatrak/posts/sangiovese-on-edge.

Wiatrak, Bryce. “Tuscany’s Mysterious Self-Making Vin Santo.” Vinous. March 2016. https://vinous.com/articles/tuscany-s-mysterious-self-making-vin-santo-mar-2016. 

Wickham, Christopher John. “Italy.” Encyclopædia Britannica. Last modified October 21, 2020. https://www.britannica.com/place/Italy.

“Wine Production by Region.” Italian Wine Central. 2020. https://italianwinecentral.com/wine-production-in-italy-by-region.

Compiled by Bryce Wiatrak (December 2020)

Edited by Sandra Ban